on Cakes and Violence

Let’s consider these two opinions together:

  • A business shouldn’t have to sell a cake (or pizza, or medicine) to someone whose personal choices they don’t agree with
  • Social media companies shouldn’t be able to kick people off their platform, even if when they promote violence

We’re hearing from people who support both of these opinions at the same time. I’d like to briefly examine how this is the worst of four possible options.

Let’s look at each option:

Option 1: Neither Cakes nor Violence

Private businesses are not required to serve anyone. This is internally consistent. You can choose to do what you want with your own property and business, so long as your aren’t infringing on others’ rights. This is the “default” mode for liberal democracy & libertarianism.

Option 2: Both Cakes and Violence

Private businesses are required to serve everyone. This is also internally consistent. This treats businesses like a public good rather than private asset. For things like social networks, that means they act more like a public utility than private business (and may even be state-run and state-owned). This is the “default” mode for social democracy & state socialism.

Option 3: Cakes but not Violence

Private businesses can’t choose who to serve based on who people innately are (or perhaps even based on what those users/customers believe), but they can otherwise reject service to those that break rules of the business or break rules that endanger the polity/society. This is the “default” mode in progressive democracy.

Option 4: Violence but not Cakes

Private businesses can reject service to people based on identity, but may be required to provide service to those that are endangering others. This is the “default” mode of fascism.

Personally, I prefer option 1 (with some additional safeguards/protections) over 3 over 2 over 4. But regardless of your preference for options 1 through 3, I hope it is clear that option 4 is the most inconsistent and dangerous of all of the positions.

✍️ Reply by email

✴️ Also on Micro.blog


Congratulations! You've found my personal blog. Take a look around and you'll find commentary, wisecracks, reviews, recommendations, reflections, quotes, and questions. Contact me and let's grow wiser, together.

Learn More

Subscribe to the newsletter

Elsewhere: RSS, Twitter, Instagram

Latest Asides

⚽️ Do I want Ronaldo or Suarez to lose more? Hard to choose.

⚽️ Maybe it’s time to admit Japan has been critically underappreciated?

⚽️ This makes me sad but it also makes me laugh, so I’ll take it:

“Belgium and Germany have been relegated to CONCACAF as a result of their performance at the WC. Them’s the rules.”

I am shocked, shocked I say, to find out the “Free Speech Activists” don’t actually care about free speech.

Picked up a physical copy of Harper’s for @ayjay’s fine article.